EPUBof a musical expressive profile, one has to explain where and how resemblances come into play. Given the appeal that its upholders make to resemblances, one can easily retort against contour theory that we do not necessarily perceive a resemblance when we hear (or see) something as expressive. It can be true that, sometimes, we notice resemblances between certain musical tones and typically expressive tones of voice, but this does not amount to saying that when we experience a piece of music as melancholy we necessarily experience it as resembling a melancholy behaviour. Rather, intuitively, things might work the other way round, that is, in virtue of the expressiveness of music, we might be led to compare it to an expressive behaviour and determine the similarities. Noticing resemblances seems not be a necessary condition to experience an expressive piece of music. As Paul Noordhof (2008) has pointed out, contour theory reflects in the phenomenal character of expressive experience a resemblance that is not (always) manifestly there. Even though a more detailed discussion of this problem will be developed in the next chapter, I shall give contour theorists the opportunity to briefly respond. A possible strategy to address this criticism appeals to an evolutionary explanation. According to Kivy (1989 and, in a more sceptical fashion, Kivy 2002 ), we are forced to hear the contour of a piece of music as an expressive behaviour in virtue of an existing resemblance, even when we
Rate this eBook
| File Name: | 204ee75f929c1149b33350ed59d01840.epub |
| Original Title: | Expressiveness |
| Creator / Author: | Marta Benenti |
| Language: | English (en) |
| Identifier: | ASIN:283187 |
| Publisher: | Marta Benenti Publishing |
| Category: | Fiction |
| Format: | 📗 EPUB eBook |
| File Size: | 3.5 MB |