EPUBof all works of literary art without exception” ( VI 1). This is explicitly not a general hermeneutics for culturally significant texts; nor is it clear that Frye is wrong, much less dangerously wrong. In reading novels, and especially poetry, are not the moods and images evoked, which differ from reader to reader, so essential to the meaning of the text that to speak of the text’s meaning in abstraction from them is to misunderstand it, along with the genre to which it belongs, from the start? When texts rely heavily on metaphors and other figures of speech, does it make sense to ask for the meaning of the text? Do we really want to assimilate the meaning of Moby-Dick or “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” to the meaning of “e=mc2” or “the cat is on the mat”? Wouldn’t that be a case of “I had to kill the patients (texts) in order to save them (from multiple interpretations)”? Similarly we would need to examine closely the texts of Eliot, Pound, Heidegger, and Jung to see whether, as Hirsch suggests, they actually affirm an autonomy of the text such that “it leads an afterlife of its own, totally cut off from the life of its author” ( VI 1-2) and, if so, just what these texts mean. Only someone who failed Logic 101 can think that to deny that the author is the sole source of meaning in a text is to present the text as “totally cut off from” the author. When the New Critics, a major target of Hirsch (and Wolter-storff), say this sort of thing, what they seem to mean is some
Rate this eBook
| File Name: | edcb25b013f3b644457ab516ea87af7b.epub |
| Original Title: | Whose Community? Which Interpretation? |
| Creator / Author: | Merold Westphal |
| Language: | English (en) |
| Identifier: | ASIN:290724 |
| Publisher: | Merold Westphal Publishing |
| Category: | Non-fiction |
| Format: | 📗 EPUB eBook |
| File Size: | 3.5 MB |




